Customers are satisfied with the quality of the shoes. They mention they're stunning, beautiful, and made of clearly superior materials. Some say the walnut color is awesome and the shoes are versatile.

'...The leather is just stunning looking, the color of it, feel of it, stitch work, the way it shines up and beams in the right light, it even smells...'

'...Look good, feel good, play good.'

'...Pros:Durable shoe, built to lastNice brogue detailsquality leather and constructionthe shoes look sharpCOMFORTABLE...'

'...Beautiful shoes and quality leather but the workmanship on these $400 shoes is absolute rubbish.'

Customers like the style of the shoes. They say they're lovely, classy, and define anyone wearing them as stylish. They also say the shoes look and feel great, go well with their suits, and are perfect for formal dress wear.

'...This is a timeless shoe that will last a long time. The leather work is excellent and the shoe is quite durable.Pros:...'

'Right shoe is great! Left shoe leather was cut by a dunce!...'

'...hurt my feet like a $100 pair of dress shoes would, and complemented my attire quite well....'

'...I think they have helped keep the shoes looking new. The shoes also smell good all day because the cedar absorbs the moisture.'

Customers appreciate the value of the shoes. They mention they're a quality pair and worth the price.

'...equity, call them Allen Edmonds, I am telling you, this shoe is worth the price and the feeling you get when you lace these cleats up for a night...'

'...cap beauty finished in walnut is the most attractive and expensive pair of shoes I have ever purchased....'

'Pricey, but nice.'

'...do', but for those of you considering whether these are worth the extra expense over similar designs from other manufacturers, the simple answer...'

Customers appreciate the shoes' attention to detail. They mention they look classy and have nice brogue details. Customers also say the shoes are a nice balance between subtle and attention-grabbing.

'...Pros:Durable shoe, built to lastNice brogue detailsquality leather and constructionthe shoes look sharpCOMFORTABLE...'

'...They are beautiful to look at and are sure to impress. I just hope that I can find a way for these to fit me better....'

'...They really are a nice balance between subtle/dressy and attention grabbing....'

'...color a little afraid it would fall into the grey category, but it’s subtle and still very dark....'

Customers like the break-in time of the shoes. They mention the insole breaks in and provides a custom fit.

'...Comfortable in every way, no break in was required. The usual stiffness I am familiar with in other new shoes was simply not there....'

'...These are amazing shoes. As you wear them, the insole breaks in and provides a custom fit to your feet....'

'...This shoe didn't take long to break in,it fits comfortable.Great shoe for what it is besides the style of the shoe.Highly recommend!!!'

'...The fit is true. There is no break-in period (at least, not for me), and they feel as good as tennis shoes!...'

Customers have mixed opinions about the comfort of the shoes. Some mention it doesn't take long to break in, fits comfortably, and feels great. Others say the D width is a little snug for them now, and the standard last runs a bit narrow.

'...The shoe feels amazing as well, after a day or two of wearing it, I broke it in and it's easily now the most comfortable shoe I've ever used....'

'...Back to the shoe, they fit great with a dark blue suit, I have seen them worn with dark jeans and the color of the shoe compliments a variety of...'

'...Left shoe leather was cut by a dunce!Leather on left side foot rubs my ankle because the shoe is a full 1/2” taller then the right shoe....'

'...I can be on my feet all day and have no aches at all. The shoes look classy and have nice brogue details....'

Customers have mixed opinions about the leather quality of the shoes. Some mention that it's beautiful, while others say it'll wrinkle in places that shouldn't, fray in parts, and have all the hallmarks of cheap leather.

'...The leather sole is also replaceable, which extends the life of this particular shoe....'

'...I don't know. One thing to note, the shoe sole was worn out pretty badly from one night of heavy activity....'

'...Durable shoe, built to lastNice brogue detailsquality leather and constructionthe shoes look sharpCOMFORTABLE...'

'...Beautiful shoes and quality leather but the workmanship on these $400 shoes is absolute rubbish.'

Customers are dissatisfied with the sizing of the shoes. They mention the shoes are longer and narrower than any comparable men's shoes. Some say the size was mismarked.

'...The big caveat is the sizing, this shoe is strange in that it's significantly longer and more narrow than your traditional shoe....'

'A little larger than I expected. Perhaps 9E would have fit better. Am going to try the 9E next time.'

'These shoes are long and narrow; Narrow! Can't even squeeze my feet into them. Wear the same size in other brands without problem....'

'Shoes are amazing. They really little big. Which Allen Edmund is famous for....'

Amazon Customer

Surprisingly comfortable for dress shoes!